Molly Little and her stepmom Mandy Rhea both have just moved in. The neighbor, Alex Mack, comes over to welcome them with a plate of cookies. Both Molly and Mandy are immediately hot for Alex, so they invite him in for coffee. Both ladies can tell that they're going to have to compete for Alex's attention, but Mandy makes the first move by suggesting Alex can be her handyman since her husband is out of town often. She has a few jobs for Alex to do right away.

While Alex is preoccupied, both girls put their plan into motion. Mandy runs to change into her sexiest lingerie, while Molly contrives to pretend she's stuck in the washing machine. Alex finds Molly first with her short skirt hiked up and her pussy hanging out. He knows what the cute little coed wants, but he's concerned that Mandy is going to find them. Molly assures him that it's fine, and Alex is about to shove it in just like they both want when Mandy arrives in the hallway and sees what they're up to. Alex hesitates, which gives Mandy time to take control of the situation by dropping to her knees and sucking the dick.

Molly isn't about to let Alex go without a fight. She shoulders her way in to suck him off, too. Realizing that the only way for both of them to win is to share, the girls take Alex to the bedroom where they finally begin working together. Alex gets to enjoy a double blowjob and then a full on threesome. Mandy gets the first go with the D as she rides him in cowgirl. Soon enough, Molly winds up on her knees with Alex banging her in doggy. She keeps her party going as she bounces away in reverse cowgirl, then cedes the cock to Mandy for the grand finale. Mandy enjoys one last climax as she lays on her back, then watches with a smile as Molly jerks Alex off onto Mandy's stomach. He leaves a nice load of cum for the ladies to share now that they've come to an arrangement that makes all of them happy.